Tutorial: Best practices when writing SWH docs

Intended audience

Members of the Software Heritage staff and external contributors who wish to contribute by writing documentation.

A tutorial on how to contribute documentation into the Software Heritage world.

Step 1: Identify your audience

  1. Ask yourself: Who are the readers of the documentation that you are writing?

    In the Software Heritage community, three general types of personas are distinguished:

    • visitors: people who want to know what is the SWH initiative and archive

    • users: people who want to use the SWH features

      • as a service

      • as a module by running a local instance

    • contributors: people who are contributing to SWH (either external or swh staff)

      • as developers

      • as sys-admins

      • as support role

  2. use the persona type to determine the document location in step 2

  3. add the intended audience on the top of the page

Step 2: Determine the documentation location

Information should have a permanent home as documentation. Elements that are work in progress can live in the forge on issues or in hedgedoc, but these are not permanent locations.

  1. Choose high-level location:

Possible permanent locations include:

  • The WordPress website: for visitors

  • The archive web-app: for visitors and users (of the interface or API)

  • The Sphinx docs:

    • devel for contributors

    • users for users of the infrastructure and all the different services

    • sysadm for sys-admins

  1. For contributors documentation in devel:

    1. Choose if the subject is a high level (cross-module) section or in a specific module

      • if the document is relative to only one module, go and add it in the /docs directory in the module

      • for cross-module documentation, use the swh-docs repository and the appropriate sub-directory (e.g architecture)

    2. Decide if a subsection is needed with multiple pages (tutorials, how-tos, reference or explanation).

  2. For sys-admin (in /sysadm folder) and user documentation (in /users folder):

    1. Check if an existing section is already describing the theme that you want to document.

    2. Decide if a subsection is needed with multiple pages (tutorials, how-tos, reference or explanation).

Step 3: Choose documentation type

We are following Divio’s approach with four major types of documentation:

  • Tutorial: allowing newcomers to get started and ease the onboarding contributors and users.

  • How to: how to solve a specific problem in a step-by-step practical manual.

  • Reference: theoretical/technical knowledge which is information oriented.

  • Explanation: theoretical knowledge understanding-oriented to analyze, discuss and explain different decisions, including background and context.

For more information see the divio documentation and/or Daniele Procida’s presentation

Note

We propose using in the following naming scheme depending on the type of document:
  • Tutorial: Tutorial name]

  • How to …

  • Reference: [Reference name]

  • Explanation: [Explanation name]

Step 4: Create a page or sub-section with multiple pages

  1. Create a .rst file with a short name of your doc in the appropriate directory (see step 2). If this is a sub-section, the first file should be an index.rst file containing the list of the current sub-section files.

  2. For not yet ready page, you can create simply create an empty page using the template below. The template starts with a reference, so that you can link to this new page from elsewhere. The page name should follow the step 3. scheme.

  3. For existing page, you can link the new page with the existing one containing the desired information.

Empty page template

.. _empty_page:

Empty page
==========

.. admonition:: Intended audience
   :class: important

   add the audience target(s) of this page

.. todo::
   This page is a work in progress. For now, please refer to the `existing documentation <https://...>`_.

Empty subsection template

.. _empty_subsection:

Empty subsection
================

.. toctree::
   :titlesonly:

   tutorial-my-first-tuto
   howto-do-things
   howto-test-stuff
   howto-dance
   reference-info
   reference-best-practices

README in module

We want to reduce redundancy in documentation as much as possible. The option we should strive for is adding a symlink to docs/README.rst in the repo’s module. Furthermore, docs/README.rst should include docs/index.rst, as following:

.. _swh-fuse:

.. include:: README.rst

.. toctree::
   :maxdepth: 1
   :caption: Overview

   cli
   configuration
   Design notes <design>
   Tutorial <tutorial>

Step 6: Commit change for code review

You should open a diff for a documentation change following the instructions in Code Review